• Skip to content (access key 1)
  • Skip to search (access key 7)
FWF — Austrian Science Fund
  • Go to overview page Discover

    • Research Radar
    • Discoveries
      • Emmanuelle Charpentier
      • Adrian Constantin
      • Monika Henzinger
      • Ferenc Krausz
      • Wolfgang Lutz
      • Walter Pohl
      • Christa Schleper
      • Anton Zeilinger
    • scilog Magazine
    • Awards
      • FWF Wittgenstein Awards
      • FWF START Awards
    • excellent=austria
      • Clusters of Excellence
      • Emerging Fields
    • In the Spotlight
      • 40 Years of Erwin Schrödinger Fellowships
      • Quantum Austria
    • Dialogs and Talks
      • think.beyond Summit
    • E-Book Library
  • Go to overview page Funding

    • Portfolio
      • excellent=austria
        • Clusters of Excellence
        • Emerging Fields
      • Projects
        • Principal Investigator Projects
        • Principal Investigator Projects International
        • Clinical Research
        • 1000 Ideas
        • Arts-Based Research
        • FWF Wittgenstein Award
      • Careers
        • ESPRIT
        • FWF ASTRA Awards
        • Erwin Schrödinger
        • Elise Richter
        • Elise Richter PEEK
        • doc.funds
        • doc.funds.connect
      • Collaborations
        • Specialized Research Groups
        • Special Research Areas
        • Research Groups
        • International – Multilateral Initiatives
        • #ConnectingMinds
      • Communication
        • Top Citizen Science
        • Science Communication
        • Book Publications
        • Digital Publications
        • Open-Access Block Grant
      • Subject-Specific Funding
        • AI Mission Austria
        • Belmont Forum
        • ERA-NET HERA
        • ERA-NET NORFACE
        • ERA-NET QuantERA
        • ERA-NET TRANSCAN
        • Alternative Methods to Animal Testing
        • European Partnership Biodiversa+
        • European Partnership ERA4Health
        • European Partnership ERDERA
        • European Partnership EUPAHW
        • European Partnership FutureFoodS
        • European Partnership OHAMR
        • European Partnership PerMed
        • European Partnership Water4All
        • Gottfried and Vera Weiss Award
        • netidee SCIENCE
        • Herzfelder Foundation Projects
        • Quantum Austria
        • Rückenwind Funding Bonus
        • Zero Emissions Award
      • International Collaborations
        • Belgium/Flanders
        • Germany
        • France
        • Italy/South Tyrol
        • Japan
        • Luxembourg
        • Poland
        • Switzerland
        • Slovenia
        • Taiwan
        • Tyrol–South Tyrol–Trentino
        • Czech Republic
        • Hungary
    • Step by Step
      • Find Funding
      • Submitting Your Application
      • International Peer Review
      • Funding Decisions
      • Carrying out Your Project
      • Closing Your Project
      • Further Information
        • Integrity and Ethics
        • Inclusion
        • Applying from Abroad
        • Personnel Costs
        • PROFI
        • Final Project Reports
        • Final Project Report Survey
    • FAQ
      • Project Phase PROFI
        • Accounting for Approved Funds
        • Labor and Social Law
        • Project Management
      • Project Phase Ad Personam
        • Accounting for Approved Funds
        • Labor and Social Law
        • Project Management
      • Expiring Programs
        • FWF START Awards
  • Go to overview page About Us

    • Mission Statement
    • FWF Video
    • Values
    • Facts and Figures
    • Annual Report
    • What We Do
      • Research Funding
        • Matching Funds Initiative
      • International Collaborations
      • Studies and Publications
      • Equal Opportunities and Diversity
        • Objectives and Principles
        • Measures
        • Creating Awareness of Bias in the Review Process
        • Terms and Definitions
        • Your Career in Cutting-Edge Research
      • Open Science
        • Open Access Policy
          • Open Access Policy for Peer-Reviewed Publications
          • Open Access Policy for Peer-Reviewed Book Publications
          • Open Access Policy for Research Data
        • Research Data Management
        • Citizen Science
        • Open Science Infrastructures
        • Open Science Funding
      • Evaluations and Quality Assurance
      • Academic Integrity
      • Science Communication
      • Philanthropy
      • Sustainability
    • History
    • Legal Basis
    • Organization
      • Executive Bodies
        • Executive Board
        • Supervisory Board
        • Assembly of Delegates
        • Scientific Board
        • Juries
      • FWF Office
    • Jobs at FWF
  • Go to overview page News

    • News
    • Press
      • Logos
    • Calendar
      • Post an Event
      • FWF Informational Events
    • Job Openings
      • Enter Job Opening
    • Newsletter
  • Discovering
    what
    matters.

    FWF-Newsletter Press-Newsletter Calendar-Newsletter Job-Newsletter scilog-Newsletter

    SOCIAL MEDIA

    • LinkedIn, external URL, opens in a new window
    • Twitter, external URL, opens in a new window
    • Facebook, external URL, opens in a new window
    • Instagram, external URL, opens in a new window
    • YouTube, external URL, opens in a new window

    SCILOG

    • Scilog — The science magazine of the Austrian Science Fund (FWF)
  • elane login, external URL, opens in a new window
  • Scilog external URL, opens in a new window
  • de Wechsle zu Deutsch

  

Long games and determinacy when sets are universally Baire

Long games and determinacy when sets are universally Baire

Sandra Müller (ORCID: 0000-0002-7224-187X)
  • Grant DOI 10.55776/V844
  • Funding program Elise Richter
  • Status ended
  • Start February 22, 2021
  • End April 21, 2023
  • Funding amount € 341,754
  • Project website
  • E-mail

Disciplines

Mathematics (100%)

Keywords

    Determinacy, Large cardinal, Universally Baire set, Long game, Descriptive inner model theory, Woodin limit of Woodin cardinals

Abstract Final report

What do we mean, when we say that something is infinite? How many different infinities are there and how do they look like? These and similar questions form the fundamental pillars of set theory, a specialization of mathematical logic. The project Long games and determinacy when sets are universally Baire is located in this area, more specifically in the subarea called inner model theory. It sits at the boundary of what can proved in mathematics and aims for a better understanding of specific infinitely large objects (so-called large cardinals). Two central notions in inner model theory are large cardinals and determinacy axioms. They are of particular importance as at a first glance as well as historically they do not have much in common. But surprisingly it was shown in the 80s that these two notions have a deep connection. Large cardinals are axioms postulating the existence of unimaginably large numbers with useful properties. Determinacy axioms have a direct impact on the structure of sets of reals, i.e., on comparatively small objects in the hierarchy of infinities. They are relatively easy to define und postulate that in certain infinite two-player-games one of the players has a winning strategy. The fact that such an easily definable statement can neither be proven nor disproven makes the notion of determinacy particularly interesting. The concrete aim of this research project is to take our current understanding of the connection between large cardinals and determinacy axioms to a new level. The results could then lead to a better understanding of our mathematical universe. In addition, they could perspectively be used to transfer known theories from one area of set theory to another one.

What do we mean, when we say that something is infinite? How many different infinities are there and how do they look like? These and similar questions form the fundamental pillars of set theory, a specialization of mathematical logic. The project Long games and determinacy when sets are universally Baire is located in this area, more specifically in the subarea called inner model theory. It sits at the boundary of what can proved in mathematics and aims for a better understanding of specific infinitely large objects (so-called large cardinals). Two central notions in inner model theory are large cardinals and determinacy axioms. They are of particular importance as at a first glance as well as historically they do not have much in common. But surprisingly it was shown in the 80s that these two notions have a deep connection. Large cardinals are axioms postulating the existence of unimaginably large numbers with useful properties. Determinacy axioms have a direct impact on the structure of sets of reals, i.e., on comparatively small objects in the hierarchy of infinities. They are relatively easy to define und postulate that in certain infinite two-player-games one of the players has a winning strategy. The fact that such an easily definable statement can neither be proven nor disproven makes the notion of determinacy particularly interesting. In this research project the connection between large cardinals and determinacy was shown at a new level. More precisely, it was shown that the existence of so-called strong and Woodin cardinals is equally strong as the axiom of determinacy in a setting where all sets of reals are universally Baire. The answers an approximately ten years old question of Grigor Sargsyan.

Research institution(s)
  • Technische Universität Wien - 100%
International project participants
  • Grigor Sargsyan, Polish Academy of Sciences - Poland
  • William Hugh Woodin, Harvard University - USA
  • John Steel, University of California Berkeley - USA

Research Output

  • 16 Citations
  • 23 Publications
  • 6 Scientific Awards
  • 5 Fundings
Publications
  • 2025
    Title Chang models over derived models with supercompact measures
    DOI 10.1142/s0219061325500072
    Type Journal Article
    Author Gappo T
    Journal Journal of Mathematical Logic
    Pages 2550007
    Link Publication
  • 2021
    Title $\Sigma_1$-definability at higher cardinals: Thin sets, almost disjoint families and long well-orders
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2110.01468
    Type Preprint
    Author Lücke P
  • 2022
    Title Perfect subtree property for weakly compact cardinals
    DOI 10.1007/s11856-022-2385-4
    Type Journal Article
    Author Hayut Y
    Journal Israel Journal of Mathematics
    Pages 865-886
  • 2023
    Title Uniformization and internal absoluteness
    DOI 10.1090/proc/16155
    Type Journal Article
    Author Müller S
    Journal Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society
    Pages 3089-3102
    Link Publication
  • 2022
    Title CONSTRUCTING WADGE CLASSES
    DOI 10.1017/bsl.2022.7
    Type Journal Article
    Author Carroy R
    Journal The Bulletin of Symbolic Logic
    Pages 207-257
    Link Publication
  • 2023
    Title Determinacy in the Chang model
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2302.06487
    Type Preprint
    Author Gappo T
  • 2023
    Title Categorically closed countable semigroups
    DOI 10.1515/forum-2022-0111
    Type Journal Article
    Author Banakh T
    Journal Forum Mathematicum
    Pages 689-711
  • 2023
    Title Determinacy Axioms and Large Cardinals
    DOI 10.1007/978-3-031-26689-8_5
    Type Book Chapter
    Author Müller S
    Publisher Springer Nature
    Pages 68-78
  • 2023
    Title An undecidable extension of Morley's theorem on the number of countable models
    DOI 10.1016/j.apal.2023.103317
    Type Journal Article
    Author Eagle C
    Journal Annals of Pure and Applied Logic
    Pages 103317
    Link Publication
  • 2023
    Title ASYMMETRIC CUT AND CHOOSE GAMES
    DOI 10.1017/bsl.2023.31
    Type Journal Article
    Author Henney-Turner C
    Journal The Bulletin of Symbolic Logic
    Pages 588-625
    Link Publication
  • 2023
    Title Chang models over derived models with supercompact measures
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2307.08607
    Type Preprint
    Author Gappo T
  • 2023
    Title -definability at higher cardinals: Thin sets, almost disjoint families and long well-orders
    DOI 10.1017/fms.2023.102
    Type Journal Article
    Author Lücke P
    Journal Forum of Mathematics, Sigma
    Link Publication
  • 2024
    Title On ?-strongly measurable cardinals in Pmax extensions
    DOI 10.1142/s0219061324500181
    Type Journal Article
    Author Aksornthong N
    Journal Journal of Mathematical Logic
    Pages 2450018
  • 2024
    Title Outward compactness
    Type Journal Article
    Author Peter Holy
    Journal arxiv
    Link Publication
  • 2023
    Title STRUCTURAL PROPERTIES OF THE STABLE CORE
    DOI 10.1017/jsl.2023.10
    Type Journal Article
    Author Friedman S
    Journal The Journal of Symbolic Logic
    Pages 889-918
    Link Publication
  • 2023
    Title Towards a generic absoluteness theorem for Chang models
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2304.07623
    Type Preprint
    Author Müller S
  • 2023
    Title Adding highly generic subsets of $\omega_2$
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2301.09435
    Type Preprint
    Author Eslami E
  • 2021
    Title The consistency strength of determinacy when all sets are universally Baire
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2106.04244
    Type Preprint
    Author Müller S
  • 2021
    Title An undecidable extension of Morley's theorem on the number of countable models
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2107.07636
    Type Preprint
    Author Eagle C
  • 2021
    Title Uniformization and Internal Absoluteness
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2108.09688
    Type Preprint
    Author Müller S
  • 2021
    Title CLOSURE PROPERTIES OF MEASURABLE ULTRAPOWERS
    DOI 10.1017/jsl.2021.29
    Type Journal Article
    Author Lücke P
    Journal The Journal of Symbolic Logic
    Pages 762-784
    Link Publication
  • 2023
    Title Determinacy and Large Cardinals
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2302.02248
    Type Preprint
    Author Müller S
  • 2022
    Title Asymmetric cut and choose games
    DOI 10.48550/arxiv.2207.09199
    Type Preprint
    Author Holy P
Scientific Awards
  • 2023
    Title Editor Thesis Abstracts in the Bulletin of Symbolic Logic
    Type Appointed as the editor/advisor to a journal or book series
    Level of Recognition Continental/International
  • 2023
    Title JMM Invited Address
    Type Personally asked as a key note speaker to a conference
    Level of Recognition Continental/International
  • 2023
    Title Bartosz Wcislo Bekker Fellowship
    Type Attracted visiting staff or user to your research group
    Level of Recognition National (any country)
  • 2022
    Title Förderungspreis der ÖMG
    Type Research prize
    Level of Recognition National (any country)
  • 2022
    Title Plenary Talk at the European Set Theory Meeting
    Type Personally asked as a key note speaker to a conference
    Level of Recognition Continental/International
  • 2022
    Title Young Academy of the ÖAW Membership
    Type Awarded honorary membership, or a fellowship, of a learned society
    Level of Recognition National (any country)
Fundings
  • 2023
    Title International Project
    Type Research grant (including intramural programme)
    Start of Funding 2023
    Funder Austrian Science Fund (FWF)
  • 2024
    Title Marie Skłodowska-Curie COFUND
    Type Fellowship
    Start of Funding 2024
    Funder Marie Sklodowska-Curie Actions
  • 2023
    Title APART-MINT Fellowship
    Type Fellowship
    Start of Funding 2023
    Funder Austrian Academy of Sciences
  • 2023
    Title START
    Type Research grant (including intramural programme)
    Start of Funding 2023
    Funder Austrian Science Fund (FWF)
  • 2024
    Title ESPRIT-Programm
    Type Research grant (including intramural programme)
    Start of Funding 2024
    Funder Austrian Science Fund (FWF)

Discovering
what
matters.

Newsletter

FWF-Newsletter Press-Newsletter Calendar-Newsletter Job-Newsletter scilog-Newsletter

Contact

Austrian Science Fund (FWF)
Georg-Coch-Platz 2
(Entrance Wiesingerstraße 4)
1010 Vienna

office(at)fwf.ac.at
+43 1 505 67 40

General information

  • Job Openings
  • Jobs at FWF
  • Press
  • Philanthropy
  • scilog
  • FWF Office
  • Social Media Directory
  • LinkedIn, external URL, opens in a new window
  • Twitter, external URL, opens in a new window
  • Facebook, external URL, opens in a new window
  • Instagram, external URL, opens in a new window
  • YouTube, external URL, opens in a new window
  • Cookies
  • Whistleblowing/Complaints Management
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Data Protection
  • Acknowledgements
  • Social Media Directory
  • © Österreichischer Wissenschaftsfonds FWF
© Österreichischer Wissenschaftsfonds FWF