Fitness-related effects of sex reversal in the agile frog
Disciplines
Biology (70%); Geosciences (30%)
Keywords
- Sex Reversal,
- Agile Frog,
- Fitness,
- Phenotype,
- Climate Change,
- Sexual Dimorphism
In mammals and birds (warm-blooded animals), the composition of sex chromosomes initiates the direction of sexual development. For example, in mammals, individuals with two copies of the X chromosome develop into females, while those with one copy of the X and one copy of the Y chromosome become males. While the presence of sex chromosomes was verified in many amphibian, reptile and fish species, experiments over the recent decades lead to the recognition that sexual development may be influenced by both internal and external factors in these cold-blooded animals. Results of these experiments indicated that if embryos or larvae are exposed to unusually high or low temperatures, the environmental conditions may override the effects of sex chromosomes. In such a case, for example, an individual carrying two copies of the X chromosome may become male instead of female. This phenomenon is called environmental sex reversal. More recently, sex-reversed individuals of some cold-blooded species have been found in nature, suggesting that sex reversal can not only be induced under artificial conditions, but may occur in wild populations as well. Because extreme temperature conditions are becoming ever more frequent due to climate change, environmental sex reversal is also expected to become more common in nature. However, we know disturbingly little about the effects of sex reversal on both individual and population level. Are sex-reversed individuals as viable as others? Can sex-reversed individuals breed and produce offspring similarly to others? These are questions important on the individuals level. However, the answers are important for the persistence of the population as well, because the perspectives of future generations depend on them. If sex reversal becomes frequent, there may be a deficit of one sex. In theory, XX individuals might all become males, and if this happens, there will be no females left and the population will go extinct. This project is focusing on the agile frog, an amphibian species of which sex-reversed XX males are known to occur in the wild. Our goal is to collect a variety of information on the prospects of sex- reversed animals for survival and mating success both by inspecting wild populations and monitoring the development of individuals in captivity. We expect that our results will enable predictions on the future of agile frog populations under the current climate change and will contribute to a better understanding of the evolution of sexual development.
In mammals and birds (warm-blooded animals), the composition of sex chromosomes initiates the direction of sexual development. For example, in mammals, individuals with two copies of the X chromosome develop into females, while those with one copy of the X and one copy of the Y chromosome become males. While the presence of sex chromosomes was verified in many amphibian, reptile and fish species, experiments over the recent decades lead to the recognition that sexual development may be influenced by both internal and external factors in these cold-blooded animals. Results of these experiments indicated that if embryos or larvae are exposed to unusually high or low temperatures, the environmental conditions may override the effects of sex chromosomes. In such a case, for example, an individual carrying two copies of the X chromosome may become male instead of female. This phenomenon is called environmental sex reversal. More recently, sex-reversed individuals of some cold-blooded species have been found in nature, suggesting that sex reversal can not only be induced under artificial conditions, but may occur in wild populations as well. Because extreme temperature conditions are becoming ever more frequent due to climate change, environmental sex reversal is also expected to become more common in nature. However, we know disturbingly little about the effects of sex reversal on both individual and population level. Are sex-reversed individuals as viable as others? Can sex-reversed individuals breed and produce offspring similarly to others? These are questions important on the individual's level. However, the answers are important for the persistence of the population as well, because the perspectives of future generations depend on them. If sex reversal becomes frequent, there may be a deficit of one sex. In theory, XX individuals might all become males, and if this happens, there will be no females left and the population will go extinct. This project focused on the agile frog, an amphibian species of which sex-reversed (XX) males are known to occur in the wild. Natural pigment patterns allowed us to monitor both captive and free-ranging individuals and collect a variety of information on the prospects of sex-reversed animals for survival and mating success. We found only subtle differences between XX and XY males in skin colouration, and they were indistinguishable in most parameters. However, we found differences in testosterone levels between the two male types. Additionally, multiple evidence together suggest that XX males are overall less successful breeders. Our findings enable more accurate predictions on the future of agile frog populations under the current climate change and contribute to a better understanding of the evolution of sexual development.
- Virginie Canoine, Universität Wien , national collaboration partner
- Bibiana Rojas Zuluaga, Veterinärmedizinische Universität Wien , mentor
- Steve Smith, Veterinärmedizinische Universität Wien , national collaboration partner
- Veronika Bókony, Centre for Agricultural Sciences - Hungary
Research Output
- 25 Citations
- 12 Publications
- 5 Datasets & models
- 4 Disseminations
- 1 Scientific Awards
- 1 Fundings
-
2026
Title Sex-reversed males are morphologically similar but have lower testosterone levels compared to sex-concordant males in the agile frog DOI 10.32942/x2mm4x Type Preprint Author Lehofer N -
2026
Title Sexual dichromatism in agile frogs: sex-reversed males closely resemble typical male coloration DOI 10.32942/x2d10p Type Preprint Author Nemesházi E -
2025
Title Put the frog in water: simple methods for improving individual identification as demonstrated with the agile frog DOI 10.1101/2025.02.25.640084 Type Preprint Author Nemesházi E Pages 2025.02.25.640084 Link Publication -
2025
Title Complex effects of sex reversal on reproductive success in wild frogs DOI 10.32942/x29s70 Type Preprint Author Bókony V -
2026
Title Placing anurans in water can improve photo-based individual identification. DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0341460 Type Journal Article Author Nemesházi E Journal PloS one -
2026
Title Photo-based individual identification is more reliable than visible implant elastomer tags or toe-tipping in young agile frogs DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0342340 Type Journal Article Author Nemesházi E Journal PLOS One -
2024
Title Interplay of genotypic and thermal sex determination shapes climatic distribution in herpetofauna DOI 10.1101/2024.04.21.589911 Type Preprint Author Nemesházi E Pages 2024.04.21.589911 Link Publication -
2023
Title HerpSexDet: the herpetological database of sex determination and sex reversal DOI 10.1038/s41597-023-02268-y Type Journal Article Author Nemesházi E Journal Scientific Data Pages 377 Link Publication -
2025
Title Photo-based individual identification is more reliable than visible implant elastomer tags or toe-tipping in young agile frogs DOI 10.1101/2025.06.19.660530 Type Preprint Author Nemesházi E Pages 2025.06.19.660530 Link Publication -
2025
Title Low genetic differentiation and symmetric migration between urban and forest populations of great tits DOI 10.1007/s42977-025-00259-1 Type Journal Article Author Mihalik B Journal Biologia Futura Pages 371-381 Link Publication -
2025
Title Weak effects of chlorpyrifos at environmentally relevant concentrations on fitness-related traits in agile frogs DOI 10.1016/j.aquatox.2025.107400 Type Journal Article Author Mikó Z Journal Aquatic Toxicology Pages 107400 -
2025
Title Interplay of Genotypic and Thermal Effects on Sex Determination Shapes Climatic Distribution in Herpetofauna DOI 10.1111/geb.70096 Type Journal Article Author Nemesházi E Journal Global Ecology and Biogeography Link Publication
-
2025
Link
Title Dataset for: Interplay of genotypic and thermal effects on sex determination shapes climatic distribution in herpetofauna DOI 10.6084/m9.figshare.25624983.v1 Type Database/Collection of data Public Access Link Link -
2025
Link
Title Data for: Placing anurans in water can improve photo-based individual identification DOI 10.6084/m9.figshare.24745293 Type Database/Collection of data Public Access Link Link -
2025
Link
Title Dataset for: Photo-based individual identification is more reliable than visible implant elastomer tags or toe tipping in young agile frogs DOI 10.6084/m9.figshare.29320697.v1 Type Database/Collection of data Public Access Link Link -
2023
Link
Title HerpSexDet database v1.1. DOI 10.6084/m9.figshare.22991651 Type Database/Collection of data Public Access Link Link -
2026
Link
Title Dataset and supplementary material for: Sexual dichromatism in agile frogs: sex-reversed males closely resemble typical male coloration DOI 10.6084/m9.figshare.31647649 Type Database/Collection of data Public Access Link Link
-
2025
Link
Title Die Presse interview Type A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview Link Link -
2025
Link
Title Toil by Lydia Cornett Type Participation in an activity, workshop or similar Link Link -
2025
Title Seminar talk at ISTA Type A talk or presentation -
2025
Title ÖGH monthly lectures Type A talk or presentation
-
2025
Title Herpetozoa Type Appointed as the editor/advisor to a journal or book series Level of Recognition Continental/International
-
2024
Title Third-party bonus (Profilinien) Type Research grant (including intramural programme) Start of Funding 2024 Funder University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna